Space,Language and Ontology: A Response to Davis |
| |
Authors: | John Bateman |
| |
Institution: | Universit?t Bremen , Bremen , Germany |
| |
Abstract: | Abstract Ernest Davis' article “Qualititative Spatial Reasoning in Interpreting Text and Narrative” discusses challenges that the interpretation of natural language appears to raise for the formalization of commonsense spatial reasoning. Davis finds these to be of “surprising logical complexity,” but also “erratic” in that they do not show a logical structuring of the problem space that could guide productive research. In this response I argue that much of the apparent lack of structure Davis laments is due to the very style of formal modeling he pursues. By augmenting logical considerations with substantial input from other disciplines and by adopting a heterogeneous and modular approach to formalization, I suggest that the problem space is by no means as ill-structured as Davis presents it. |
| |
Keywords: | spatial ontology spatial language spatial semantics qualitative spatial representation and reasoning |
|
|