Comments on `Detector relative efficiencies in the presence ofLaplace noise' by M.I. Dadi and J.R. Marks II

In the above-titled paper (see ibid., vol.AES-23, p.568-82, July 1987) M.I. Dadi and J.R. Marks II studied the relative efficiencies of the Neyman-Pearson optimal detector with respect to the linear and sign detectors, for the detection of a constant signal in additive Laplace noise. By applying the central limit theorem, they derived expressions for three types of asymptotic relative efficiencies (AREs). However, as noted in the above paper, the Gaussian approximation to the sign detector fails to yield the correct asymptotic efficiency. The commenter derives the correct ARE of the optimal detector with respect to the sign detector for the Laplace noise