The coronal loop controversy: TRACE analysis

The temperature distribution along coronal loops provides an important clue for solving the coronal heating problem. Recent analysis, however, has produced conflicting results. Here, we analyze in detail one component of this analysis – the effect of background subtraction on the temperature of loops observed with the Transition Region and Coronal Explorer (TRACE). Specifically, we selected 10 coronal loops that were visible in the TRACE 171 Å and 195 Å passbands. We chose between 20 and 30 pixel along each loop and background pixels to correspond with the loop pixels. Temperature analysis was done in three different ways: (1) standard TRACE analysis of the loop pixels with no background subtraction; (2) constant background subtraction for each TRACE image; (3) pixel pair background subtraction. Each method produced a temperature estimate for the selected pixels. We find that a flat line is an excellent fit to the temperature results – the analysis indicates that the temperature of the loop is uniform along the length visible by TRACE. However, if we select random pixels and plot the temperature results in the same way, these pixels indicate that the temperature of this “structure” is also uniform. We conclude therefore, that in the cases considered here, the image ratio analysis does not produce a physically meaningful value of plasma temperature; in addition, background subtraction makes no significant difference to the temperatures results.