有人-无人机协同空战机动决策研究

目前，有关无人机空战的研究主要考虑无人机的完全自主决策机动算法，关于有人机有限监督决策下的空战机动决策的研究鲜有报道，更缺乏对有人—无人机协同作战的研究。为实现无人机协同空战过程中的自主机动，设计一种基于路径规划技术的有人—无人机协同空战机动决策模型。首先，引入动态栅格环境，自适应调整栅格规模和分辨率，以弥补静态栅格环境规划空间越大规划效率越低的缺陷；然后，将A star 算法规划路径作为参考路径，提出ACO-A star 混合路径规划算法，以提升ACO 算法的寻优效能；最后，基于均值聚类算法设计有人—无人机协同空战机动决策算法。进行空战对抗仿真模拟，结果表明：所提出的算法具有更好的决策正确性，可有效提升空战胜率。     

Three-dimensional cooperative guidance strategy and guidance law for intercepting highly maneuvering target

Cooperative interception of the target with strong maneuverability by multiple missiles with weak maneuverability in the three-dimensional nonlinear model is studied. Firstly, the three-dimensional nonlinear model of cooperative guidance is established. The three-dimensional reachable region is represented composed of lateral acceleration and longitudinal acceleration in the two-dimensional coordinate system. Secondly, the problem of the multiple missile's reachable coverage area is transformed into the problem of cooperative coverage. A cooperative coverage strategy is proposed and an algorithm for quickly calculating the number of required missiles is designed. Then, the guidance law based on the cooperative coverage strategy is proposed, and it is proved that cooperative interception of the target can be achieved under the acceleration limit. Moreover, the relations among the number of missiles, the initial array position of terminal guidance and the coverage area of the target’s large maneuver are analyzed. The dynamic adjustment strategy of guidance parameters is proposed to reduce the guidance error. Finally, simulation results show that multiple missiles with low maneuverability can achieve effective interception of target with strong maneuverability through the proposed cooperative strategy and cooperative guidance method.     

虚拟多触角探测的高超声速滑翔飞行器再入机动制导

针对高超声速滑翔飞行器再入过程中面对的多约束问题，提出一种基于虚拟多触角探测的路航点规划机动制导策略。该机动制导策略通过飞行器最大转弯轨迹计算速度-剩余地面距离-航向角约束，在分段定点模式中发出多条粗略预测触角，引用触角末端反馈的信息计算优先级以确定临时路航点；同时在机动制导模式中发出精细探测触角，计算触角末端信息优先级，经倾侧角延时滤波器得出控制指令，对飞行器进行机动制导。基于多触角探测的路航点规划机动制导策略，降低了三触角机动制导方法中的计算时间；同时，4种典型禁飞区条件下的仿真结果表明，该策略能够有效稳定地解决机动制导过程中的多约束问题。     

多架无人作战飞机攻击行为的协调

建立了基于Agent的无人作战飞机指挥控制系统的形式化语义模型，提出了无人作战飞机编队的联合作战目标、联合作战意图和协同攻击效能的定义，以及结合联合作战意图、协同作战效能的多架无人作战飞机编队攻击行为的协调方法。仿真结果表明，结合联合作战意图和协同攻击效能的攻击行为可有效地提高编队的作战效能。     

基于粗糙集理论的编队协同空战决策规则提取

为了对空战过程中大量的冗余信息进行约简，以提高空战决策的实时性，将粗糙集理论引入到编队协同空战战术决策研究中，提出了一种用于提取空战关键信息和战术决策规则的属性约简算法。并将单一决策属性下的属性值约简方法推广，讨论了更适于编队作战分析的多决策属性下的属性值约简问题。最后，通过一个编队空战战术选择示例对该算法进行了验证，结果表明：空战的冗余信息是可以约简的；此算法可提取出对空战起主要作用的属性，即雷达／中距弹信息；并且在保证空战关键分类结果不变的情况下，可生成用于战术决策的最小简化策略，所提取的决策规则与编队空战的实际相符合。     

多机空战指挥引导不平衡目标分配方法研究

目前,存在多机空战指挥引导不平衡目标分配模型少的问题,提出一种新的多机空战不平衡目标分配方法。结合空战理论与实际,在现有模型的基础上,利用最优控制理论,建立多机空战指挥引导目标分配模型;介绍匈牙利算法和进化匈牙利算法的基本思想和流程,在此基础上将匈牙利算法和进化匈牙利算法相结合来寻求最优方案,并进行仿真分析。结果表明:该方法具有较好的时效性和可靠性,能满足多维条件下的目标分配处理,满足实战需求,为解决多机空战指挥引导不平衡目标分配问题拓展了研究思路。     

Cooperative differential games guidance laws for multiple attackers against an active defense target

This paper is concerned with a scenario of multiple attackers trying to intercept a target with active defense. Three types of agents are considered in the guidance: The multiple attackers, the target and the defender, where the attackers aim to pursuit the target from different directions and evade from the defender simultaneously. The guidance engagement is formulated in the framework of a zero-sum two-person differential game between the two opposing teams, such that the measurements on the m...     

领弹控制下的多导弹时间协同三维制导律

采用领弹一被领弹策略,在三维空间内设计了一种多导弹时间协同制导律。领弹在俯仰和偏航2个通道都采用增广比例导引,而被领弹在俯仰通道采用增广比例导引,但在偏航通道采用机动控制。该机动控制使被领弹与领弹在偏航面内达到时间协同,即在偏航面内被领弹与领弹的弹道曲率大小（相对于速度而言）趋于一致。俯仰通道上的增广比例导引使被领弹与领弹在该通道上的前置角逐渐趋于0,致使它们的弹道完全落于偏航面内,最终实现被领弹与领弹的协同,这意味着被领弹按照领弹的攻击时间攻击目标。在设计被领弹偏航通道的机动控制指令时,采用了动态逆方法。仿真结果验证了方法的有效性。     

A joint mid-course and terminal course cooperative guidance law for multi-missile salvo attack

Salvo attacking a surface target by multiple missiles is an effective tactic to enhance the lethality and penetrate the defense system. However, existing cooperative guidance laws in the mid-course or terminal course are not suitable for long- and medium-range missiles or stand-off attacking. Because the initial conditions of cooperative terminal guidance that are generally generated from the mid-course flight may not lead to a successful cooperative terminal guidance without proper mid-course flight adjustment. Meanwhile, cooperative guidance in the mid-course cannot solely guarantee the accuracy of a simultaneous arrival of multiple missiles. Therefore, a joint mid-course and terminal course cooperative guidance law is developed. By building a distinct leader-follower framework, this paper proposes an efficient coordinated Dubins path planning method to synchronize the arrival time of all engaged missiles in the mid-course flight. The planned flight can generate proper initial conditions for cooperative terminal guidance, and also benefit an earliest simultaneous arrival. In the terminal course, an existing cooperative proportional navigation guidance law guides all the engaged missiles to arrive at a target accurately and simultaneously. The integrated guidance law for an intuitive application is summarized. Simulations demonstrate that the proposed method can generate fast and accurate salvo attack.     

一种基于信息一致性的卫星编队协同控制策略

提出一种基于信息一致性的分布式协同控制策略,实现了卫星编队的构型建立、保持与整体机动。首先根据编队各星的初始相对状态,应用一阶一致性算法,协商估计出编队整体系统基准参考点的相对状态;再根据编队整体系统模型预测方程,以凸优化方法规划出期望重构机动路径;之后设计了基于二阶一致性算法的反馈协同控制律,使各星彼此协同地跟踪期望路径与构型、整体机动参考信息,并证明了系统的稳定性。仿真结果表明:只要在基准参考点一致性估计过程中信息拓扑图中存在最大生成树,该策略就能实现卫星编队的协同机动;反馈协同控制律能有效消除相对初始状态误差与地球非球形摄动J2项引起的各星状态偏离,并具有较好的容错性;与传统方法相比,本文方法在燃料消耗总量与均衡性方面均有所改善,且在构型快速建立或重构时,燃料消耗总量方面优势较为明显。     

自主近距空战中机动动作库及其综合控制系统

针对自主近距空战中机动动作库的设计,采用定性与定量结合的方法对机动动作进行描述,以准确体现机动动作的几何形态和战术意义,构成含描述参数的机动动作库。对于机动动作的控制,提出了按照任务控制-运动学控制-动力学控制-被控对象划分的综合控制系统多层递阶结构。其中,机动动作控制器针对每种机动动作分别设计指令生成器,生成气流角和速率指令;气流角控制器采用含指令滤波的backstepping方法进行控制律设计。以半滚倒转和高速摇摇为例进行仿真验证,仿真结果表明,机动动作的描述参数能准确体现其几何形态和战术意义,并通过综合控制系统实现有效控制。     

飞行器集群协同制导控制方法及应用研究

分析了目前多飞行器协同作战的发展现状与趋势，指出了多飞行器以编队形式进行协调与配合，可以有效提高突防概率与作战效能。针对飞行器集群协同制导控制技术，分析梳理了相关的技术难点。然后，分别对协同任务规划与动态目标分配方法和多飞行器编队协同控制方法、多约束条件下的分布式协同制导方法的国内外研究现状进行了介绍。最后对飞行器集群协同制导控制技术进行了总结，并对未来的发展方向进行了展望。     

基于博弈论的自由空战指挥引导对策问题研究

博弈论是解决空战对抗问题的有效方法之一,针对目前自由空战筹划困难、指挥引导对策单一的现状,在现有空战博弈问题研究的基础上,扩展了机动动作库和控制参数,加入了雷达开机时机这一关键决策,分别从静态博弈和动态博弈角度出发,提出了构建自由空战指挥引导对策模型的思路,为下一步指挥引导对策模型的研究奠定了基础.     

Cooperative formation control of multiple aerial vehicles based on guidance route in a complex task environment

In recent years, formation control of multi-agent has been a significant research subject in the field of cooperative control. However, previous works have mainly concentrated on formation control for simple point-mass model and linear model. In contrast, this paper presents a novel cooperative algorithm for multiple air vehicles formation control, which aims to devise a control strategy based on guidance route to achieve precisely coordinated formation control for a group of fixed-wing aircraft in a complex task environment. The proposed method introduces the leader-follower structure for effective organization of the multi-agent coordination. Moreover, the Partial Integrated Formation and Control (PIFC) is adopted to design the control law for Guidance-Route based Formation Control (GRFC). Additionally, the proposed approach designs two guidance-route generation strategies for two special situations to demonstrate the effectiveness of GRFC in complex task environments. Theoretical analysis reveals that the proposed control protocol for guidance command can ensure the overall stability and tracking accuracy of the system. Numerical simulations are performed to illustrate the theoretical results, and verify that the proposed approach can achieve coordinated formation control precisely in a complex task environment.     

自主空战连续决策方法

未来空战正朝着无人化、自主化方向发展,自主空战决策方法是未来空战的重要支撑手段之一。传统空战决策方法由于维度限制,存在无法处理连续动作与远视决策的问题。基于Actor-Critic 方法提出空战连续决策的统一架构,依据空战训练经验对状态空间、动作空间、奖励及训练科目进行合理设计,测试多种连续动作空间强化学习算法在高不确定性空战场景下的学习效果并进行可视化验证。结果表明：基于本文提出的方法架构,可以实现连续动作下的远视价值寻优,智能体可以在复杂空战态势下做出最优决策,对随机机动飞行目标有较高的击杀率,且空战机动轨迹具有较高的合理性。     

有人/无人机协同作战运用研究现状与展望

有人/无人机协同是未来作战样式的重要发展方向,对于加快发挥无人机装备的作战价值,与有人机形成优势互补、协同高效的作战体系具有重要意义。首先,总结了近年来国内外在有人/无人机协同作战方面的重点研究项目进展;然后,阐明了有人/无人机协同作战的协同关系与指挥架构,并从规划控制的角度梳理了该领域涉及的关键技术(主要包括协同任务分配、协同航迹规划以及协同飞行控制);最后,对未来有人/无人机协同作战运用的研究发展方向进行了总结和展望。     

有向拓扑条件下针对机动目标的分布式协同制导律设计

研究了在有向拓扑条件下针对机动目标的分布式协同制导律的设计问题。首先，根据飞行器与目标之间追击过程的几何关系建立制导过程系统模型，针对该模型的非线性问题采用动态反馈线性化方法进行处理。将目标未知机动视为干扰，通过扩张状态观测器进行观测，同时将该估计值用于制导律的设计中，通过直接补偿的方式剔除目标机动对飞行器剩余飞行时间的影响。然后，将所设计的制导律代入到制导模型中，利用一致性分析方法将多飞行器协同制导问题转化为一致性问题，利用极点分析的方法对非一致性子空间的收敛性进行分析，得到协同制导律收敛的充要条件。最后，通过仿真分析的方式对所设计的协同制导律以及制导律的参数选取方法进行分析。     

Differential-game-based guidance law using target orientation observations

Modern 4th generation air-to-air missiles are quite capable of dealing with today's battlefield needs. Advanced aerodynamics, highly efficient warheads and smart target acquisition systems combine to yield higher missile lethality than ever. However, in order to intercept highly maneuverable targets, such as future unmanned combat air vehicles (UCAV), or to achieve higher tracking precision for missiles equipped with smaller warheads, further improvement in the missile guidance system is still needed. A new concept is presented here for deriving improved differential-game-based guidance laws that make use of information about the target orientation, which is acquired via an imaging seeker. The underlying idea is that of using measurements of the target attitude as a leading indicator of target acceleration. Knowledge of target attitude reduces the reachable set of target acceleration, facilitating the computation of an improved estimate of the zero-effort miss (ZEM) distance. In consequence, missile guidance accuracy is significantly improved. The new concept is applied in a horizontal interception scenario, where it is assumed that the target maneuver direction, constituting a partial attitude information, can be extracted via processing target images, acquired by an imaging sensor. The derivation results in a new guidance law that explicitly exploits the direction of the target acceleration. The performance of the new guidance law is studied via a computer simulation, which demonstrates its superiority over existing state-of-the-art differential-game-based guidance laws. It is demonstrated that a significant decrease in the miss distance can be expected via the use of partial target orientation information.     

BVR空战仿真中具有分层学习能力的CGF实体行为仿真框架设计

针对超视距协同空战仿真是一个复杂系统的仿真特点,通过对预警机指挥引导下的多机协同空战过程的分析,建立了超视距多机协同空战行为功能框架,总结出多机协同空战过程中的影响因素。在分析了现有各种CGF系统体系结构及行为仿真框架基础上,结合超视距空战过程中各作战阶段的特点,建立了具有分层学习能力的编队协同空战自主兵力系统FCAF(Formation and Cooperative Air Combat Autonomous Force System,编队协同空战自主兵力系统)行为仿真框架,并给出了该行为仿真框架组成模块的形式化描述。仿真系统应用表明,在该框架中作战行为可以分解为一系列具有经验学习功能的行为基,并且各行为基可以重新组合,全面诠释了协同作战行为仿真的作战过程。     

基于控制变量参数化的主动反拦截突防最优控制计算方法

针对由于敌防空系统防御能力不断提高所带来的进攻导弹突防难题,提出主动反拦截突防(IAIP)的概念,以弥补传统机动突防仅考虑进攻导弹的逃逸而忽略其攻击任务的缺陷。根据IAIP制导的内涵,在综合考虑目标的机动性能、拦截导弹末段的拦截特性及进攻导弹的控制系统性能的基础上,建立进攻导弹-目标-拦截导弹的三体运动模型。将突防制导指令的设计等效为最优控制的求解,其中突防指令为实现燃料最省目标的最优解,进攻导弹的过载、拦截导弹的脱靶量、进攻导弹的攻击角、打击精度和突防后的视线角,分别为控制约束、路径约束和末端约束。借鉴控制变量参数化(CVP)方法将最优控制问题转化为非线性数学规划问题,并将路径约束离散化后采用序列二次规划(SQP)算法得到突防时机给定条件下制导指令的数值解。提出基于CVP的混合遗传算法(CVP-GA),用于求解最优突防时机及制导指令。仿真结果显示,采用IAIP最优控制算法的进攻导弹在成功突防后的打击精度仍可满足任务要求,且其燃料消耗相对于传统串联式突防方法降低了23.7%,验证了该方法的有效性及优越性。